Check out my latest presentation at AEJMC 2012 in Chicago.
Hang on for upcoming reviews of additional books as well. I've been vacationing from blogging this summer but not reading! Coming soon: A review of Joan Didion's Slouching Towards Bethlehem.
In the mean time:
http://www.slideshare.net/klcolley/best-practices-in-student-media-marketing
Saturday, August 11, 2012
Thursday, June 7, 2012
Books Journalists Should Read, No. Definitely No.
The Kitchen God’s
Wife by Amy Tan
This is the
second Amy Tan book I’ve read. The first one was The Joy Luck Club, which was
very similar to the movie of the same name. However, it was easier to
understand when you were changing narrators in the movie. Again, Tan uses this
device of changing narrators without giving the reader a clear indication of
the change. Truly confusing at times.
While Tan gives
some great insight into Chinese culture, traditions and history, this book
really reads like The Joy Luck Club. Especially in the beginning. After the
first few chapters, I had to close the book, look at the cover and make sure I
wasn’t reading The Joy Luck Club. Does that make the book repetitive? Well yes.
I believe it does, which is one of the biggest problems I see with this book.
It just seems like a rehash of The Joy Luck Club in parts, which is why I
wouldn’t recommend this book as a must read for journalists. Although not on
the College Media Advisers list of books that journalists should read, Tan is an accomplished
writer who gives a different perspective from the male-dominated, white,
middle-class perspective offered in so many of the books on CMA’s list. But
just because it’s different doesn’t mean it’s better.
Tan does give
some great visual images, and I would recommend The Kitchen God’s Wife to my
International and Intercultural Communications class. It would also be a good
read for a Women’s studies class. But the storytelling and writing don’t rise
to the levels of must read.
Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Books That Writers Should Read, Yes
Angela's Ashes by Frank McCourt
Note: I have not seen the movie based on the book.
A New York Times #1 bestseller and winner of the Pulitzer Prize, this book is a memoir from Frank McCourt. It gives a vivid description of the poverty and resultant disease that he endured growing up as a child in Ireland.
Even though McCourt wasn't a journalist, he was an English teacher, he provides a very powerful lead and nut graph on the very first page of Chapter 1. After this, it's just the details:
"My father and mother should have stayed in New York where they met and married and where I was born. Instead, they returned to Ireland when I was four, my brother, Malachy, three, the twins, Oliver and Eugene, barely one, and my sister, Margaret, dead and gone.
"When I look back on my childhood I wonder how I survived at all. It was, of course, a miserable childhood: the happy childhood is hardly worth your while. Worse than the ordinary miserable childhood is the miserable Irish childhood, and worse yet is the miserable Irish Catholic childhood."
Wow--that says it all. The poverty, the senselessness, the hopelessness, the omnipresent, yet foreboding Catholic Church in Ireland, the death and the unhappiness. But what makes this book worth the reading is the little boy that McCourt uses to tell his story. Little Frankie McCourt tells a tale as only a child can, and it is this voice that makes the misery bearable.
Along the way in Angela's Ashes, McCourt buttresses almost every Irish stereotype, providing real-world examples from his family: a father who drinks and drinks and drinks. A family subservient to the Catholic Church, often to their detriment. Potatoes...lots of potatoes. And of course wonderful stories and singing. This book has it all. But first and foremost, it is a great story, well-written. And that my friends, is why Angela's Ashes is a must-read book for all communicators.
Note: I have not seen the movie based on the book.
A New York Times #1 bestseller and winner of the Pulitzer Prize, this book is a memoir from Frank McCourt. It gives a vivid description of the poverty and resultant disease that he endured growing up as a child in Ireland.
Even though McCourt wasn't a journalist, he was an English teacher, he provides a very powerful lead and nut graph on the very first page of Chapter 1. After this, it's just the details:
"My father and mother should have stayed in New York where they met and married and where I was born. Instead, they returned to Ireland when I was four, my brother, Malachy, three, the twins, Oliver and Eugene, barely one, and my sister, Margaret, dead and gone.
"When I look back on my childhood I wonder how I survived at all. It was, of course, a miserable childhood: the happy childhood is hardly worth your while. Worse than the ordinary miserable childhood is the miserable Irish childhood, and worse yet is the miserable Irish Catholic childhood."
Wow--that says it all. The poverty, the senselessness, the hopelessness, the omnipresent, yet foreboding Catholic Church in Ireland, the death and the unhappiness. But what makes this book worth the reading is the little boy that McCourt uses to tell his story. Little Frankie McCourt tells a tale as only a child can, and it is this voice that makes the misery bearable.
Along the way in Angela's Ashes, McCourt buttresses almost every Irish stereotype, providing real-world examples from his family: a father who drinks and drinks and drinks. A family subservient to the Catholic Church, often to their detriment. Potatoes...lots of potatoes. And of course wonderful stories and singing. This book has it all. But first and foremost, it is a great story, well-written. And that my friends, is why Angela's Ashes is a must-read book for all communicators.
Labels:
Angela's Ashes,
book review,
communicators,
Frank McCourt,
Irish,
writing
Friday, May 11, 2012
Books Journalists Should Read, Definitely No, Unless You're a Hunter Thompson Fan
The Rum Diary by
Hunter S. Thompson
Disclaimer: I
have not watched the movie The Rum Diary starring Johnny Depp.
Instead, I read
this book because it was on the list…yes the list of books compiled by members
of the College Media Advisers listserv. The list that all journalists should
read.
In this case,
I’d have to disagree. While The Rum Diary is entertaining, and Hunter S.
Thompson is a talented writer, this isn’t a must-read book for all journalists.
This book is a loving and longing reflection on a time that was the height of
romantic journalism—lots of drinking, hamburgers for breakfast, lunch and
dinner, easy, beautiful women who fall for journalists, and party, party, party
on the beach. Who wouldn’t want to lovingly remember such a lifestyle? Unfortunately,
the glamorized world of Paul Kemp is more Earnest Hemingway than reality. Too
bad, because it’s wildly entertaining.
Thompson does
work in some gems of writing throughout The Rum Diary. Like this bit on
writers:
“Most people who
deal in words don’t have much faith in them and I am no exception—especially
the big ones like Happy and Love and Honest and Strong. They are too elusive
and far too relative when you compare them to sharp, mean little words like
Punk and Cheap and Phony. I feel at home with these, because they’re scrawny
and easy to pin, but the big ones are tough and it takes either a priest or a
fool to use them with any confidence.”
Cuts right to
the quick doesn’t it.?
Much of The Rum
Diary gives some similar cheap shots at luck, friendship, Puerto Rican media,
Puerto Rican police, journalists and flacks. Allusions to famous films,
gangsters and lazy natives abound in this thin novel, with ascerbic commentary
and booze-filled nights.
If you’re a
journalist’s journalist, Thompson provides all of the cynicism and worldly
pleasures expected, including a shot of rum with a get-out-of-jail chaser.
That’s probably the charm associated with The Rum Diary, and probably one of
the reasons that anything by Hunter S. Thompson was included on this list. Some
more discerning listers specified Thompson’s Fear and Loathing books. I’ll be
reading those next.
Wednesday, May 9, 2012
Books Everyone Should Read, Really
The Shining by
Stephen King
Disclaimer: I
have watched the movie The Shining starring Jack Nicholson and Shelley Duvall.
Okay, so this
book veers from the list of books compiled by members of the College Media
Advisers listserv, but I’ve never read The Shining and a girl needs some
entertainment every now and then.
And entertaining
this book is. A hotel that basically comes to life, including blood, guts on
the wall and murdered gangsters and their girlfriends (and sometimes boyfriends
too). Hedge animals that move, bite, tear and grab, but ultimately fall prey to
gasoline and fire. But scariest of all, the tightly-wound father who comes
unraveled based on imaginary liquor and over-inflated sense of self.
Of course in the
movie, the tightly-wound father is the character to watch, so aptly played by
Nicholson, but the true focus of this book is The Shining, those people with
the ability to read minds and see the future. In this case, Jack’s son and
namesake, who sees and hears much scarier things in the book than he does in
the film. I’ve found this to be the case with all Stephen King book’s I’ve
read: They’re much scarier than the movies.
I’m not a big
scary movie, scary book person, but Stephen King is one of the best writers of
our time. He’s also one of the most prolific, delving into the psyche and
plumbing the depths of what makes each of us get the skin-crawling sensation
that gives us bad dreams, or keeps us up at night.
As usual, King’s
writing is something to be emulated by all good communicators. Direct and
descriptive, King cuts to the heart of the matter.
The story, while
creepy, is a bit out there as believability goes. However, it still induced a
couple of wide-eyed nights as I read some of the most supernatural and
unbelievable parts.
Recently, I told
several students at Texas A&M University, that the best way to improve as a
writer is to read. Well here’s a chance for students to read something that may
be of more interest than their textbooks. While you’re reading, enjoy the entertainment,
but pay attention to the writing. It’s so good, you’ll forget to pay attention.
Now that’s what I call a great writer.
Monday, April 2, 2012
Books Everyone Should Read, Really
Talent Is Overrated: What Really Separates World-Class Performers from Everybody Else by Geoff Colvin
Okay, so this book isn’t on College Media Adviser’s list of books journalists should read, but this is definitely a book everyone should read—journalists, communications professionals, educators, athletes, musicians, you name it. Everyone will find the tools needed to be the best in this book. And as the title indicates, it isn’t talent.
So what is it that separates the so-so performer from the good to the truly excellent world-class performer? Deliberate practice.
Yes I know. We’ve all heard the axiom, “Practice makes perfect.” But that’s not what Colvin means. What Colvin means is deliberate, meaningful, planned, systematic and difficult practice that allows you, the performer to practice a skill over-and-over-and-over.
It’s doing as Benjamin Franklin did to practice his writing…It’s finding prose superior to anything he had seen. In this case, the Spectator by Joseph Addison and Richard Steele. He read an article. Took brief notes on the meaning of each sentence. A few days later, he would look at the notes and try to express the meaning in his own words. He would then compare his words to the original to discover his faults. His discovery: a poor vocabulary.
Franklin discovered that he could improve his vocabulary by writing poetry, which required a large stock of words with extensive knowledge of meaning and hue. So he rewrote the essays from the Spectator into verse. Then, he would rewrite the verse into prose after he had forgotten the meanings.
Not content to just work on vocabulary, he discovered a method to improve his organizational skills. He would write notes on each sentence in the essay on separate pieces of paper. After a week, he would put all of the pieces together to form the essay and compare to the original. Each time, Franklin would review his work for faults and start all over again. Sounds like a lot of work.
This is precisely why most of us don’t make it to expert. It’s a lot of work. Work isn’t fun.
Deliberate practice isn’t fun, but it does produce the truly world-class performer, with or without talent.
Another such example of deliberate practice at work was one of the most prolific professional football players of all-time, Jerry Rice, who played until age 42. His personal training regime was one that the 49ers’ trainer wouldn’t release for fear that others might hurt themselves.
Here were the hallmarks of Rice’s training regime, as analyzed by Colvin:
• He spent very little time playing football.
• He designed his practice to work on his specific needs.
• It wasn’t fun.
• He defied the conventional limits of age.
So according to Colvin, deliberate practice changes people in fundamental ways, turning people into experts who exhibit these qualities:
• They understand the significance of indicators that average performers don’t even notice.
• They look further ahead.
• They know more from seeing less.
• They make finer discriminations than average performers.
• And they remember more.
What does this mean for all of us? Well we can be superstars without talent.
All it takes is several hours (read about 8 hours per day if you haven’t started in your youth) to become prodigies. Good to know I can still become a world-class concert pianist.
Well, maybe I’ll just learn to play cool music…Maybe that won’t take as much practice time. So pull up a bench. Where’s my metronome?
Okay, so this book isn’t on College Media Adviser’s list of books journalists should read, but this is definitely a book everyone should read—journalists, communications professionals, educators, athletes, musicians, you name it. Everyone will find the tools needed to be the best in this book. And as the title indicates, it isn’t talent.
So what is it that separates the so-so performer from the good to the truly excellent world-class performer? Deliberate practice.
Yes I know. We’ve all heard the axiom, “Practice makes perfect.” But that’s not what Colvin means. What Colvin means is deliberate, meaningful, planned, systematic and difficult practice that allows you, the performer to practice a skill over-and-over-and-over.
It’s doing as Benjamin Franklin did to practice his writing…It’s finding prose superior to anything he had seen. In this case, the Spectator by Joseph Addison and Richard Steele. He read an article. Took brief notes on the meaning of each sentence. A few days later, he would look at the notes and try to express the meaning in his own words. He would then compare his words to the original to discover his faults. His discovery: a poor vocabulary.
Franklin discovered that he could improve his vocabulary by writing poetry, which required a large stock of words with extensive knowledge of meaning and hue. So he rewrote the essays from the Spectator into verse. Then, he would rewrite the verse into prose after he had forgotten the meanings.
Not content to just work on vocabulary, he discovered a method to improve his organizational skills. He would write notes on each sentence in the essay on separate pieces of paper. After a week, he would put all of the pieces together to form the essay and compare to the original. Each time, Franklin would review his work for faults and start all over again. Sounds like a lot of work.
This is precisely why most of us don’t make it to expert. It’s a lot of work. Work isn’t fun.
Deliberate practice isn’t fun, but it does produce the truly world-class performer, with or without talent.
Another such example of deliberate practice at work was one of the most prolific professional football players of all-time, Jerry Rice, who played until age 42. His personal training regime was one that the 49ers’ trainer wouldn’t release for fear that others might hurt themselves.
Here were the hallmarks of Rice’s training regime, as analyzed by Colvin:
• He spent very little time playing football.
• He designed his practice to work on his specific needs.
• It wasn’t fun.
• He defied the conventional limits of age.
So according to Colvin, deliberate practice changes people in fundamental ways, turning people into experts who exhibit these qualities:
• They understand the significance of indicators that average performers don’t even notice.
• They look further ahead.
• They know more from seeing less.
• They make finer discriminations than average performers.
• And they remember more.
What does this mean for all of us? Well we can be superstars without talent.
All it takes is several hours (read about 8 hours per day if you haven’t started in your youth) to become prodigies. Good to know I can still become a world-class concert pianist.
Well, maybe I’ll just learn to play cool music…Maybe that won’t take as much practice time. So pull up a bench. Where’s my metronome?
Monday, March 19, 2012
Books Journalists Should Read, Not Really
Never Let Them See You Cry: More from Miami, America's Hottest Beat by Edna Buchanan
This book is a continuation of Buchanan's life as a police beat reporter with the Miami Herald and all of the strange tales she experienced in America's Hottest Beat. A reminder: I am an Edna Buchanan fan.
Buchanan wrote this book after the publication of her first novel, so this book is likely designed to play on the popularity of The Corpse Had a Familiar Face, her first nonfiction book about life as a police beat reporter in Miami.
And Buchanan doesn't disappoint, providing some of the trademark razor-sharp writing and observations that keep her the reigning queen of the police beat despite more than two decades of absence from her domain.
In describing a victim of crime:
"Ethel Lottman, a no-nonsense Miami Beach widow, seventy-two, handled her heart condition, her arthritis and a homicidal maniac with the same aplomb."
A description of the new South Beach:
"Sleepy South Beach, once famous for its senior citizens, now throbs through the soft nights with a healthy and and youthful energy, more lusty and alive than it has ever been."
While this book covers familiar ground in stories of murder and mayhem in Miami, it does break new ground. The last chapter also goes into Buchanan's struggle to embrace her new life as a novelist and drop her old journalistic habits.
This book marks the end of Buchanan's nonfiction, journalistic writing as she becomes what she had always dreamed of--a writer. A great loss for journalism.
The Corpse Had a Familiar Face was vintage Edna Buchanan at her journalistic best. Never Let Them See You Cry doesn't reach that level of journalistic technique in writing, analysis and reporting. It does foreshadow the crime novel career of Buchanan, one that is still going.
Never Let Them See You Cry is a must read if you are an Edna Buchanan fan. Otherwise, stick with The Corpse Had a Familiar Face. It provides more journalistic juice from the world's best police beat reporter, which is a crying shame.
This book is a continuation of Buchanan's life as a police beat reporter with the Miami Herald and all of the strange tales she experienced in America's Hottest Beat. A reminder: I am an Edna Buchanan fan.
Buchanan wrote this book after the publication of her first novel, so this book is likely designed to play on the popularity of The Corpse Had a Familiar Face, her first nonfiction book about life as a police beat reporter in Miami.
And Buchanan doesn't disappoint, providing some of the trademark razor-sharp writing and observations that keep her the reigning queen of the police beat despite more than two decades of absence from her domain.
In describing a victim of crime:
"Ethel Lottman, a no-nonsense Miami Beach widow, seventy-two, handled her heart condition, her arthritis and a homicidal maniac with the same aplomb."
A description of the new South Beach:
"Sleepy South Beach, once famous for its senior citizens, now throbs through the soft nights with a healthy and and youthful energy, more lusty and alive than it has ever been."
While this book covers familiar ground in stories of murder and mayhem in Miami, it does break new ground. The last chapter also goes into Buchanan's struggle to embrace her new life as a novelist and drop her old journalistic habits.
This book marks the end of Buchanan's nonfiction, journalistic writing as she becomes what she had always dreamed of--a writer. A great loss for journalism.
The Corpse Had a Familiar Face was vintage Edna Buchanan at her journalistic best. Never Let Them See You Cry doesn't reach that level of journalistic technique in writing, analysis and reporting. It does foreshadow the crime novel career of Buchanan, one that is still going.
Never Let Them See You Cry is a must read if you are an Edna Buchanan fan. Otherwise, stick with The Corpse Had a Familiar Face. It provides more journalistic juice from the world's best police beat reporter, which is a crying shame.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)